January 11, 2024

To subscribe to this FREE weekly newsletter simply email jellison@san.rr.com with “subscribe” as the subject.

LITIGATION TRACKER ... Trump Trials Clearinghouse

https://www.justsecurity.org/88175/trump-trials-clearinghous

THE WEEK'S BEST QUOTES. . .

“I think you only do it if someone’s found guilty. So, you know, what I’ll say is this is about moving the country forward, and the last thing we want to see is an 80-year-old former president sitting in jail” — Nikki Haley when, in an interview on Fox News, she was asked if she would pledge to pardon Trump preemptively or only if he was found guilty.  https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4391848-haley-says-she-would-only-pardon-trump-if-hes-found-guilty/
 

Nobody is looking Joe Biden straight in the eye and saying to him, “You’re going to lose this thing.” It doesn’t happen in the White House. It doesn’t happen in politics. She (his wife) is the only one who could do this. And clearly she’s not doing it. — Frank Luntz on whether Biden will step aside before the election. https://www.thefp.com/p/2024-predictions-honestly-bari-weiss

“Shoot me.” — Nate Silver, when asked, “Gun to your head, who is going to win: Trump or Biden?” https://www.thefp.com/p/2024-predictions-honestly-bari-weiss

“They could be healthy, they could be very unhealthy, they could bring in disease that’s going to catch on in our country, but they do bring in crime, but they have them coming from all over the world. And they’re destroying the blood of our country. They’re destroying the fabric of our country.”  — Trump echoing the rhetoric of Adolf Hitler, who wrote in “Mein Kampf” that German blood was being poisoned by Jews. https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4368808-trump-dismisses-hitler-comparisons-over-immigration-rhetoric

“The threat to our democracy is real, present and urgent.” -- Nancy Pelosi. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/01/three-years-after-january-6-capitol-insurrection-trump/677024/

“Our nation can survive and recover from policy mistakes. We cannot recover from a president willing to torch the Constitution. Speak for us all. Tell the world who we are with your vote. Tell them that we are a good and a great nation. But make sure they know that we do not bend, we do not break and we do not yield in the defense of our freedom. Show the world that we will defeat the plague of cowardice sweeping through the Republican party.” —  Liz Cheney imploring New Hampshire voters to use their presidential primary to send a message to the world. https://apnews.com/article/liz-cheney-trump-new-hampshire-gop-campaign-3d219b6369ba1c42acd52fc5f590d03d


“I would rather saw my arm off with blunt glass than vote for Trump.” — Meghan McCain. https://twitter.com/meghanmccain/status/1743806050799628669

In the USA, you don’t need government issued ID to vote and you can mail in your ballot. This is insane. — Elon Musk https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1744498282141786473

“You’re the epitome of white privilege, coming into the oversight committee, spitting in our face, ignoring a congressional subpoena to be deposed. You have no balls to come up here.” — Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) after Hunter Biden attended a hearing to consider contempt charges against him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDcpFK2V15I&t

“The Civil War was so fascinating, so horrible. So many mistakes were made. See, there was something I think could have been negotiated, to be honest with you. I think you could have negotiated that. All the people died, so many people died. You know, that was the disaster.” — DonaldTrump, who went on to suggest that “Abraham Lincoln, of course, if he negotiated it, you probably wouldn’t even know who Abraham Lincoln was.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/01/06/trump-says-civil-war-could-have-been-negotiated-historians-disagree/

 

VIDEOS ...

President Biden almost slipped up and called Donald Trump a “sick fxck” during a speech marking the anniversary of the Capitol riots. https://twitter.com/Angry_Staffer/status/1743372712515420484

“All I know about magnets is this, give me a glass of water, let me drop it on the magnets, that’s the end of the magnets.” — Trump the scientist. https://twitter.com/Acyn/status/1743463970621862227

“We do have the technology now, and we’re going to build a giant dome over our country to protect us from a hostile source. And I think it’s a great thing, and it’s going to all be made in the United States.”— Trump the military genius. https://themessenger.com/politics/trump-calls-for-giant-dome-to-protect-the-us-from-a-hostile-source

The Biden-Harris campaign launched their first ad of 2024 on the anniversary of January 6, highlighting MAGA extremism’s existential threat to American democracy.

NBC News reporter Vaughn Hillyard asked Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) a question:
HILLYARD: If Trump is found guilty and wins the nomination, would you stand by him at the convention?
DeSANTIS: (walks away without an answer). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l00JOtvLqMkswering
“The answer is ‘Yes’ I would defund the IRS. I think the IRS is a corrupt organization and I think it’s not a friend to the average citizen or taxpayer. We need something totally different.” —Gov. Ron DeSantis, when asked, saying he would be welcome a measure from Congress to defund the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) if he’s elected president next year. https://twitter.com/DeSantisWarRoom/status/1662440382154588168

IN THIS ISSUE

IN THE NEWS

OPINION

IN THE NEWS...  

Israeli calls for Gaza’s ethnic cleansing are only getting louder

The human misery unfurling across Gaza finds little sympathy in the Israeli public discourse, where the priority remains the vanquishing of Hamas — perpetrators of the single bloodiest slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust — and the freeing of hostages held in Hamas’s Gazan redoubts. Indeed, a steady drumbeat of sound bites from Israeli lawmakers and other politicos has urged an even more devastating fate for the territory.

Members of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing coalition have called for the dropping of a nuclear bomb on densely-populated Gaza, the total annihilation of the territory as a mark of retribution, and the immiseration of its people to the point that they have no choice but to abandon their homeland.

This week alone, a parliamentarian from Netanyahu’s Likud party went on television and said it was clear to most Israelis that “all the Gazans need to be destroyed.” Then, Israel’s ambassador in Britain told local radio that there was no other solution for her country than to level “every school, every mosque, every second house” in Gaza to degrade Hamas’s military infrastructure. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/01/05/wv-israel-hamas/

The Potency of Propaganda

Facts have little bearing on the sentiment inside the Republican Party, which has been fed a steady diet of lies and half truths by Fox News and the rest of the sprawling right-wing media machine. To wit, the false notion that Joe Biden nefariously stole the 2020 election is now widely shared inside the GOP. A CNN poll conducted over the summer found that nearly 70% of Republicans believe Biden's win was not legitimate, a number that has continued to tick up.

In other words, the Big Lie that led to the 2020 insurrection is now the dominant thinking among Republicans. https://view.newsletters.cnn.com/messages/17044267428625716fa3b920b/raw

A quarter of Americans believe FBI instigated Jan. 6, Post-UMD poll finds

Twenty-five percent of Americans say it is “probably” or “definitely” true that the FBI instigated the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, a false concept promoted by right-wing media and repeatedly denied by federal law enforcement, according to a new Washington Post-University of Maryland poll.

The Post-UMD poll finds a smaller 11 percent of the public overall thinks there is “solid evidence” that FBI operatives organized and encouraged the attack, while 13 percent say this is their “suspicion only.”

Among Republicans, 34 percent say the FBI organized and encouraged the insurrection, compared with 30 percent of independents and 13 percent of Democrats.

The results confirm that misinformation about Jan. 6 is widespread as the United States heads into a presidential election year, during a campaign in which the former president and leading 2024 Republican candidate Donald Trump has repeatedly expressed support for those who participated in the insurrection. Despite a detailed congressional investigation and more than 725 completed federal prosecutions of Jan. 6 participants that did not yield evidence of FBI involvement, a substantial minority of Americans still embrace conspiracy theories not unlike the ones that drove many rioters to storm the Capitol three years ago.

“The people that went there to express their views, to support Trump, were peaceful,” said Richard Baum, 61, an independent voter from Odessa, Tex. “The government implants were the violent ones: the FBI, the police people that were put in there, the antifa and BLM hired by George Soros; everybody knows that. https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2024/01/04/fbi-conspiracy-jan-6-attack-misinformation/

Florida surgeon general calls for halt on mRNA covid vaccines, citing debunked claim

Florida’s top health official called for a halt to using mRNA coronavirus vaccines on Wednesday, contending that the shots could contaminate patients’ DNA — a claim that has been roundly debunked by public health experts, federal officials and the vaccine companies.

"We’ve seen this pattern from Dr. Ladapo that every few months he raises some new concern and it quickly gets debunked,” said Ashish Jha, dean of Brown University’s public health school who led the White House’s national coronavirus response before stepping down last year. “This idea of DNA fragments — it’s scientific nonsense. People who understand how these vaccines are made and administered understand that there is no risk here. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2024/01/03/florida-surgeon-general-ladapo-covid-vaccine/
 

Justice Department Sues Texas Over Law That Would Let Police Arrest Migrants Who Enter U.S. Illegally

The Justice Department on Wednesday sued Texas over a new law that would allow police to arrest migrants who enter the U.S. illegally, taking Republican Gov. Greg Abbott to court again over his escalating response to border crossers arriving from Mexico. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/justice-department-sues-texas-over-law-that-would-let-police-arrest-migrants-who-enter-us-illegally_n_6595e628e4b0bf73e1784300

SpaceX illegally fired workers critical of Elon Musk, U.S. labor agency says

Rocket and satellite maker SpaceX on Wednesday was accused by a U.S. labor agency of unlawfully firing eight employees for circulating a letter calling founder and CEO Elon Musk a “distraction and embarrassment.”

A regional official with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) issued a complaint claiming SpaceX violated the workers’ rights under federal labor law to band together and advocate for better working conditions.

The letter sent to SpaceX executives in June 2022 focused on a series of tweets Musk had made since 2020, many of which were sexually suggestive. The employees claimed Musk’s statements did not align with the company’s policies on diversity and workplace misconduct, and called on SpaceX to condemn them.

The complaint also accuses SpaceX of interrogating employees about the letter, disparaging the workers who were involved, and threatening to fire workers who engaged in similar activity.

The case is the latest to accuse companies run by Musk of violating employees’ rights under labor and employment laws. https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/spacex-illegally-fired-workers-critical-elon-musk-us-labor-agency-says-rcna132250

White House for Sale: How Princes, Prime Ministers, and Premiers Paid Off President Trump

By elevating his personal financial interests and the policy priorities of corrupt foreign powers over the American public interest, former President Trump violated both the clear commands of the Constitution and the careful precedent set and observed by every previous Commander-in- Chief.

 Article I Section 9 , Clause 8 of the Constitution forbids the President to accept money payments or gifts of any kind whatever from foreign governments and monarchs unless he obtains the Consent of the Congress to do so . Yet Donald Trump, while holding the office of president, used his business entities to pocket millions of dollars from foreign states and royalty and never once went to Congress to seek its consent. This report sets forth the records showing foreign government money and all the spoils from royals we can find pouring into hotels and buildings that the President continued to own during his presidency, all in direct violation of the Constitutional prohibition. https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/352377138e125817/849dad00-full.pdf

January 6 Still a Big Liability for Trump

Democrats and independents still hold starkly negative views of Jan. 6, its participants and Trump’s role in stoking the riot. Majorities of Americans overall still believe now-President Joe Biden was elected legitimately, that Trump is guilty of trying to steal the election and that the federal criminal charges in Washington against Trump are appropriate.

Even as surveys generally show Trump running even with the unpopular Biden or leading him narrowly in the horse race, Trump’s refusal to concede the last election and his actions leading up to the Capitol riot are significant liabilities for his candidacy.

And it’s not just a poll-based hypothetical that direct ties to Jan. 6 or broader denial of the 2020 election results are a millstone for Trump and his aligned candidates. Only 14 months ago, voters in the midterms rejected the majority of 2020 election deniers — especially in battleground states — despite a political environment and generic ballot that otherwise favored Republicans. https://politicalwire.com/2024/01/06/january-6-still-a-big-liability-for-trump

Drug that Trump called a ‘miracle Covid cure’ is linked to 17,000 deaths in new study

A drug infamously touted by Donald Trump has been linked to nearly 17,000 Covid deaths in a new scientific study.

Researchers say that the anti-malaria drug hydroxychloroquine was prescribed to patients during the first wave of Covid-19 despite the absence of evidence documenting its clinical benefits.

The French study estimated that 16,990 patients in the US, France, Belgium, Italy, Spain and Turkey may have died as a result of the drug. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/trump-drug-covid-deaths-hydroxychloroquine-b2474022.html

‘Election deniers’ are still running Congress three years after January 6

Three years after a violent breach of the US Capitol that stopped the certification of millions of Americans’ votes, nearly one-third of its elected members have denied the election’s outcome, including 127 sitting members of Congress who refused to certify the 2020 results.

Those members – who supported legal battles to reverse results, voted against them, or promoted election conspiracy theories – represent voters in 37 states.

They include 19 Senators and 152 members of the House of Representatives, including its Republican speaker, labelled the most powerful election denier in Washington. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/election-denier-congress-jan-6-trump-b2473943.html

China spent over $5.5 million at Trump properties while he was in office

The Chinese government and its state-controlled entities spent over $5.5 million at properties owned by Donald Trump while he was in office, the largest total of payments made by any single foreign country known to date, according to financial documents cited in a report from House Democrats released Thursday.

Those payments collectively included millions of dollars from China’s Embassy in the United States, a state-owned Chinese bank accused by the US Justice Department of helping North Korea evade sanctions and a state-owned Chinese air transit company. https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/04/politics/trump-properties-china-foreign-payments/index.html
 

THE DAILY GRILL

“I’m leaving it on the table. I’m not gonna say I’m gonna go file it tomorrow night. I’m not saying I’m not gonna file it tomorrow. I think the speaker needs to know that we’re angry about it.” — Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX), who would not rule out a motion to vacate against Speaker Mike Johnson. https://twitter.com/Olivia_Beavers/status/1744837637221888278

VERSUS

“If they try it, they are fucking idiots.” —  Rep. Mike Lawler (R-NY) warning hardline Republicans to not even think about attempting to oust Speaker Mike Johnson, https://www.semafor.com/article/01/09/2024/johnson-budget-vacate-moderates

OPINION  

Jackie Calmes: 2023 was the year of the do-nothing House Republicans. In 2024, they’ll do worse than nothing

It’s a new year but the same old mess in Congress. Instead of a fresh start, lawmakers return next week to their stale, dead-end arguments and legislative gridlock.

And by now the reason they’re mired in the mess is an old story: Repeatedly in 2023, we saw the dysfunction of the MAGA Republicans who narrowly took control of the House last January, making that chamber virtually ungovernable and yielding one of the least productive years in Congress’ history. Just a couple dozen mostly minor bills became law, a fraction of the usual number.

The House and Senate broke for the holidays still bloodied from the unfinished sausage-making. To borrow another lawmaker metaphor, they kicked the can down the road — cans, plural — into 2024.

Yet agreement on lingering issues — spending, Ukraine aid, immigration — hardly comes more easily in an election year; the distractions of the presidential primaries start this month, in Iowa and New Hampshire. Then there is the House Republicans’ greatest distraction of all: their top-priority push to impeach President Biden, on grounds still TBD.

What we’re in for in 2024 is more of the misrule that results when one of our two major parties morphs from a small-government party into an unabashedly anti-government bloc. https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2024-01-04/washington-congress-government-shutdown-ukraine-israel-taiwan-aid

Philip Bump: There’s new evidence of foreign money going to a president: Trump

The heart of the Republican effort to potentially (or probably: inevitably) impeach President Biden are business agreements involving his son Hunter Biden. Even before Republicans took control of the House a year ago, party leaders, such as then-incoming House Oversight Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.), announced their intention to explore how money from foreign actors might have made its way through Hunter Biden to his father. When then-House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) opened an impeachment inquiry in September, he cited a need to figure out how money might have flowed to the president — though he did not claim, as others have, that this had already been demonstrated.

On Thursday, members of the Oversight Committee finally offered actual concrete evidence of a president benefiting from an influx of foreign money. This isn’t particularly useful for the Republican impeachment effort, though: The president at issue was Donald Trump.

It’s worth pointing out that this has always been the problem with the Republican targeting of Biden. Their insistence on the nefariousness of layered corporations or money from overseas was always more applicable to Trump and his family than to Biden and his. Comer repeatedly claimed that one of his desired goals is to come up with rules governing how presidential family members might leverage their relationships, but he has also repeatedly ignored evidence of how Trump’s family — and Trump himself — did so. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/01/04/trump-foreign-money

 

Susan B. Glasser: The Ghost of January 6th Haunts 2024

The long shadow of January 6, 2021, hangs over this election. Three years after a mob of Americans stormed their own Capitol, seeking to block Joe Biden’s victory and keep Donald Trump in the White House, Biden and Trump each began 2024 with plans to make the tragic events of that day the centerpiece of his campaign. For the incumbent, it’s the rationale for his entire Presidency and the most compelling reason to give him a second term—a continuation of the “battle for the soul of America” that animated Biden’s run in 2020. For Trump, it’s the false battle cry around which he hopes to rally the maga mob once again. Already, he has proved that millions of his supporters are immune to the truth about January 6th. It will be an incredible act of political sorcery if he can ride his lies about the 2020 election and its violent aftermath back into the White House. And yet, as the year begins, his chances of doing so are better than ever.

To his original Big Lie about the “rigged election” in 2020, Trump has added ever more lies. He now calls January 6th “a beautiful day” and the nearly thirteen hundred defendants arrested in connection with the attack on the Capitol martyrs and “hostages.” In recent months as he has campaigned for his return to the White House, he has dangled pardons for the insurrectionists, to be issued “on Day 1” of his second term, and threatened instead to lock up the police who tried to defend the Capitol that day. “When people who love our country protest in Washington, they become hostages unfairly imprisoned for long portions of their life,” he told a rally in Iowa last month.

This rhetoric is likely only to escalate in the course of the campaign, as Trump faces both a federal and a state trial on criminal charges connected with his efforts to overturn the 2020 election results. In fourteen states, meanwhile, there is pending litigation to keep Trump off the ballot on the ground that his role in inciting the events of January 6th makes him an “insurrectionist” as defined by the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution—a matter soon to make its way to the Supreme Court since both Colorado and Maine have already disqualified him from their ballots. Trump’s legal team is also challenging the federal case against him, on the basis that his extraordinary post-2020-election acts were part of his official duties and thus covered by Presidential “immunity.” One thing we can pretty much say for sure about 2024 is that not a day will go by without the ghost of January 6th echoing loudly in our courtrooms and in our politics.

The Republicans’ modern-day political alchemist has, in just three years, made 2020-election denialism—and its corollary set of falsehoods about January 6th—a core tenet in the Republican catechism. Who’s to say where this will all end up? The prospect of Trump restored as President, back in the Oval Office on January 20, 2025, pardoning himself and all the other “hostages” seems a lot more real than it did three years ago. https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-bidens-washington/the-ghost-of-january-6th-haunts-2024

Molly Jong-Fast: Donald Trump’s Tirades Barely Make a Blip

Developments in Trump’s legal cases grab headlines (while raising major  constitutional issues), but the former president seems to keep skating by; according to the polls, he’s thriving. The MAGA faithful have surely seen his mad rants, but persuadable voters, who aren’t plugged into Truth Social or far-right media, could’ve missed them given the relative lack of mainstream attention. Journalists may no longer be shocked or even surprised by Trump’s words and actions, but it’s no time to ignore them.

Maybe Trump benefits from the last eight-plus years of lowering the bar—his history of tweeting incendiary things, making racist remarks, and lying incessantly about the last election has perhaps made him essentially immune from accountability, and so nothing sticks. In 2016, Trump rode the outrage news cycle to victory, and now, two elections later, his abhorrent views and wannabe dictator behavior barely make a blip on the media radar.

Will such “business as usual” coverage lull less plugged-in voters into thinking that Trump is behaving like a conventional candidate and would, somehow, act like a “normal” president? https://www.vanityfair.com/news/donald-trump-2024-media

Steven Shepard: Why Jan. 6 is a problem for Trump’s campaign

As the GOP appears poised to formally line up behind Trump as its standard-bearer this November, fewer Republicans today call the rioters criminals or say the judicial punishments they’ve received are appropriate than in the immediate aftermath of the Capitol attack, polls show.

That’s helped ease Trump’s path to the nomination. But those shifts in public opinion haven’t extended to the rest of the electorate, including independents, suggesting a continued danger for Republicans and an opening for Democrats: GOP voters may increasingly brush it aside, but the Jan. 6 riot continues to be toxic in a general election.

The findings of two polls released this week underscore the risk for the GOP in tapping Trump again, just as Republicans in Iowa and New Hampshire prepare to cast the first votes in the primary contest.

Democrats and independents still hold starkly negative views of Jan. 6, its participants and Trump’s role in stoking the riot. Majorities of Americans overall still believe now-President Joe Biden was elected legitimately, that Trump is guilty of trying to steal the election and that the federal criminal charges in Washington against Trump are appropriate.

Even as surveys generally show Trump running even with the unpopular Biden or leading him narrowly in the horse race, Trump’s refusal to concede the last election and his actions leading up to the Capitol riot are significant liabilities for his candidacy.

And it’s not just a poll-based hypothetical that direct ties to Jan. 6 or broader denial of the 2020 election results are a millstone for Trump and his aligned candidates. Only 14 months ago, voters in the midterms rejected the majority of 2020 election deniers — especially in battleground states — despite a political environment and generic ballot that otherwise favored Republicans.

Trump may have succeeded in moving GOP voters away from their immediate revulsion after Jan. 6, but the broader electorate is less likely to come onboard in November. https://www.politico.com/news/2024/01/06/jan-6-trump-biden-00134147

 

Dan Pfeiffer:  How the GOP Became the Party of Insurrection

Three years later, the Republican Party is now an insurrectionist party. Trump is stronger than ever and the undisputed leader. He is more popular among Republicans than during his presidency and leading Joe Biden in the polls — something that never happened during the 2020 cycle. Nearly every Republican of consequence has endorsed his presidential campaign; and even those yet to endorse him explicitly or implicitly, endorsed the idea that the 2020 election was stolen. The few Republicans who actively stood up to Trump have been drummed out of the primary…

Standing by the Big Lie that led to January 6th is the price of admission into the GOP. You have to either believe the election was stolen or pretend to believe it. Apocalyptic rhetoric and kooky conspiracies are the norm…

The process by which the Republican Party went from shunning Trump to embracing him and his authoritarian, anti-democratic rhetoric happened steadily and stunningly. Trump’s second rise to power is a metaphor for everything that is wrong with the Republican Party. Trump didn’t reclaim the Republican Party by force. Instead, party leaders handed it to him out of cynical convenience and pure cowardice. https://www.messageboxnews.com/p/how-the-gop-became-the-party-of-insurrection

NY Times Editorial Board: A Warning About Donald Trump and 2024

At the outset of this election year, with Donald Trump leading the race to be the Republican presidential nominee, Americans should pause to consider what a second Trump term would mean for our country and the world and to weigh the serious responsibility this election places on their shoulders.

Mr. Trump has made clear his conviction that only “losers” accept legal, institutional or even constitutional constraints. He has promised vengeance against his political opponents, whom he has called “vermin” and threatened with execution. This is particularly disturbing at a time of heightened concern about political violence, with threats increasing against elected officials of both parties.

He has repeatedly demonstrated a deep disdain for the First Amendment and the basic principles of democracy, chief among them the right to freely express peaceful dissent from those in power without fear of retaliation, and he has made no secret of his readiness to expand the powers of the presidency, including the deployment of the military and the Justice Department, to have his way.

Re-electing Mr. Trump would present serious dangers to our Republic and to the world. This is a time not to sit out but instead to re-engage. We appeal to Americans to set aside their political differences, grievances and party affiliations and to contemplate — as families, as parishes, as councils and clubs and as individuals — the real magnitude of the choice they will make in November. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/06/opinion/trump-2024-campaign-warning.html

Frank Bruni: Trump’s Final Battle Has Begun

Like many other Americans struggling to find scraps of calm and slivers of hope in this anxious era, I resolved a while back not to get overly excited about Donald Trump’s overexcited utterances. They’re often a showman’s cheap histrionics, a con man’s gaudy hyperbole.

But I can’t shake a grandiose prophecy that he made repeatedly last year as he looked toward the 2024 presidential race. He took to calling it the “final battle.”

I first heard Trump use that phrase in March, when he addressed the Conservative Political Action Conference. I laughed at his indefatigable self-aggrandizement. He said it again weeks later at a rally in Waco, Texas, not far from where the deadly confrontation between the Branch Davidians and federal law enforcement officials took place. I cringed at his perversity.

But as he continued to rave biblically about this “final battle,” my reaction changed, and it surprised me: He just may be right. Not in his cartoonish description of that conflict — which pits him and his supporters against the godlessness, lawlessness, tyranny, reverse racism, communism, globalism and open borders of a lunatic left — but in terms of how profoundly meaningful the 2024 election could be, at least if he is the Republican presidential nominee. And if he wins it all? He will probably play dictator for much longer than a day, and the America that he molds to his self-interested liking may bear little resemblance to the country we’ve known and loved until now.

And Joe Biden, who campaigned in 2020 on a promise to unify the country and prides himself on bipartisanship, has recognized in his own way that “final battle” is apt. He has suggested that he is running again, at the age of 81, because the unendurable specter of Trump back in the White House leaves him no other choice. Trump and Biden don’t depict each other simply as bad alternatives for America. They describe each other as cataclysmic ones. This isn’t your usual negative partisanship, in which you try to win by stoking hatred of your opponent. It’s apocalyptic partisanship, in which your opponent is the agent of something like the end of days.

Trump talks that way all the time, ranting that we’ll “no longer have a country” if Biden and other Democrats are in charge. Biden’s warning about Trump is equally blunt, and it could assume ever greater prominence as he calculates how to win re-election despite widespread economic apprehension, persistently low approval ratings and attacks on his age and acuity.

“Let’s be clear about what’s at stake in 2024,” he said at a campaign event in Boston last month. “Donald Trump and his MAGA Republicans are determined to destroy American democracy.”

If the people on the losing side of an election believe that those on the winning side are digging the country’s graveyard, how do they accept and respect the results? The final battle we may be witnessing is between a governable and an ungovernable America, a faintly civil and a floridly uncivil one. And it wouldn’t necessarily end with a Trump defeat in November. It might just get uglier.

The final battle may be between resignation and determination, between a surrender of our ideals and the resolve to keep reaching for them, no matter how frequently and how far we fall short. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/02/opinion/trump-biden-election.html